Every time it came up
Discussion of multiple endings, Frodo vs Sam as hero, extended edition length, character arcs, and concluding scenes
Taylor ✓ voice-verified▲ positive
“I think Sam is the hero. I think that Frodo is a hero. I think that he is the main hero”
Kyle · likely▲ positive
“It's kind of hard to improve on. Kind of perfection. I love it. I'm going to watch it again.”
Taylor ✓ voice-verified◆ mixed
“it ends so many times i love lord of the rings and when i get to the end of the return of the king extended i'm like guys you gotta pace it here”
Brief comparison of Return of the King's ending to Inglourious Bastards' ending structure
Taylor ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“it should have ended in the lull and then they like back up a bit with the forest thing”
Discussion of The Lord of the Rings conclusion, rewatching it, special effects aging, and specific scenes
Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative
“I didn't like some of the spider fighting and the damn web they wrapped around him. He looked stupid to me.”
Woody ✓ voice-verified▲ positive
“I watched Return of the King recently. it's good it's good some of the effects do not hold up as well as i remembered”
Kyle compares his hypothetical reaction to a plane crash situation to Denethor's despair at seeing the orcs approaching
Kyle ✓ voice-verified● neutral · passing mention, not scored
“I would have been like Denithor when he sees the orcs outside. I would have been like flee flee.”
Extensive discussion of Return of the King comparing book to movie, analyzing Battle of Pelennor Fields, Witch King vs Gandalf, ghost army, and Tom Bombadil character.
Kyle ✓ voice-verified◆ mixed
“I don't like that liquidly moving across and I also likeed his point about the uh the NZ ghoul”
Woody · unverified◆ mixed
“I I don't mind it but like I also don't think that like the gondorian soldiers that died died for nothing”
Kyle · unverified▼ negative
“I watched a couple of commercials to so I could didn't have to buy the thing and Zach be's advertised I I've always thought that is the weakest part by far uh because it trivializes everything that came before it”
Discussion of a memorable scene with Theoden's speech before the Battle of Pelennor Fields, considered one of the best battle introductions in film
Taylor ✓ voice-verified▲ positive
“I could have convinced myself at that 12 13 years old to be like pee in a cup just pee in this cup you cannot miss the the Battle of pelor fields right now”
Kyle · unverified▲ positive
“is that the one where he's like there's a day where the courage of men will fail but that's not this day yes it was good that delivering speeches like that is so much harder than you think”