Rookie of the Year (1993) film

Discussion of the film's realism regarding a child breaking his arm and becoming a professional baseball player, debate about its plausibility

Woody ✓ voice-verified▼ negative

“the most unrealistic part of rookie of the year the movie where the child broke his arm and now it became a catapult for baseballs and he played major league baseball was that anyone would allow a child to play”

Taylor ✓ voice-verified◆ mixed

“It would be funny if they had a scene in Rookie of the Year where after the game, all his teammates are like, come on, take a shower.”

Discussed in comparison to The Rookie; about a child who gets injured and becomes a major league player

Kyle ✓ voice-verified◆ mixed

“And then it's so much better than the rookie of the year, which is when that child just slips and hurts his arm and gets to be a major league player.”

Kyle ✓ voice-verified▲ positive

“I liked that movie.”

Discussion about the film with the boy who can throw fast after breaking his arm

Taylor ✓ voice-verified▲ positive · passing mention, not scored

“I loved. I remember watching Don't they don't they run like a weird play”

Hutch · unverified▲ positive

“Rookie of the Year. Yes. Incredible movie. Just unbelievably stupid premise, but now loving that.”

1990s sports fantasy about kid with magically fast pitching arm that helps him pitch professionally

Kyle · unverified▲ positive

“I love that one too that's the one that made me think that like eating ribs would make me big and strong”